Wednesday, February 2, 2011

The Knife of Never Letting Go by Patrick Ness

Posted by Simcha 5:13 PM, under | 7 comments

Todd Hewitt is the youngest boy in Prentisstown and in just a month he will become a man.
Todd knows the history of Prentisstown; how the families had arrived twenty years ago from another planet, in search of a place to settle and build a hopeful future. But upon arrival the men caught a virus called Noise which caused their thoughts to float freely in the air, for everyone to hear, and then the women all sickened and died, including Todd’s mother. So now there are no more women, no more children and no more silence.

But just because everyone’s thoughts can be heard doesn’t mean that secrets can’t still be concealed. When Todd is sent into the swamp on an errand by his foster father he is shocked by the discovery of a void within the Noise. Inside one of the decrepit buildings in the swamp he senses a space of pure silence, something that he had never imagined even existed. But because of this discovery Todd is forced to flee Prentisstown, although he has no idea why.

If you intend to read The Knife of Never Letting Go make sure to start early in the morning, on a day when you don’t have anything else planned, because once you begin you won’t want to put this book down.

The story begins right as Todd and his talking dog Manchee (because animals have also been effected by the Noise virus) make the discovery which will forever change Todd’s life. From that point on the tension quickly escalates and the pace speeds up so that I found myself tearing through the pages, unable to put the book down. Ness certainly knows how to pull readers in and keep them hooked. By offering tantalizing hints about Prentisstown’s secrets, without actually revealing very much, the story held me captive until the very end, when all is finally revealed.

But while the story is fast paced and intense I never found the tension too overwhelming, as I sometimes do with such books. There were some well placed interludes in the story that give both the characters and the readers a chance to catch their breath and rest for a bit, before things heated up again. For me this is important because if a book is unrelentingly dark and grim I sometimes have trouble getting myself to keep reading it, bit this was never the case here.

The book's protagonists are engaging and sympathetic, especially Todd, in whose voice the story is told. He comes across as both innocent and fierce. He longs to become a man, counting down each day until his birthday, though at the same time he struggles to understand what being a man actually entails.

Now I want to make a few comments about the ending which I was pretty disappointed with for several reasons, which I will explain in a bit more depth below. While I don’t intend to give a way any spoilers you still might want to skip the next couple of paragraphs if you haven’t yet read the book. If you have read it I would be interested in hearing what your thoughts are.

So, I was not at all happy with the discouraging way the story ended. I wanted the end to provide some meaning and purpose for Todd’s difficult travails; some remuneration other than just a Big Reveal (most of which I had already figured out by then). Instead Todd gets a shocking disappointment that seems to land him back in square one and a cliff hanger that makes me wary about picking up the next book. Who wants to open a door knowing there is a tiger on the other side, about to pounce?

I was also unsatisfied with the reasoning given for why Aaron and the Prentisstown men were hunting Todd. Neither motive made much sense to me and I felt let-down when all the cards were finally put on the table.

---End of spoiler----

While I thoroughly enjoyed The Knife of Never Letting Go the disappointing ending has left me a little wary about reading the sequels, just in case Ness follows the same pattern there. If not for the unsatisfying ending I would have ranked The Knife of Never Letting Go up there with one of my favorite YA dystopia books, The Hunger Games. But despite my feeling about the way the book is concluded I still say it's an excellent book that I would highly recommend.


great write up, I've been hearing good things all over the place about The Knife of Never Letting Go.

although I did skip thru the last few paragraphs of your review, as I haven't read the book yet, and i don't want anything to be spoiled. ;)

After I read the second and third books, I found myself, let's say, reassessing the stated motive for the Mayor to raise the army to come after Todd. In case that helps.

If you aren't a fan of the cliffhanger (I'm usually not either), be warned that The Ask and the Answer has a similarly cliffhangery ending with a similar impact. But as long as you have the third book next to you while you are reading the second, there's no reason to let that bother you. And the third book made everything worthwhile, I truly feel. (Though I adored all three of the books, so I am not an unbiased judge.)

This is the series that opened my mind about the Dystopian Fiction genre. Normally, I would have dismissed any book that includes the words "space ship," but in the case of the Chaos Walking series, I would have seriously missed out. While I understand your frustration with the cliff hanger ending, these books are worth it! And they have all been released, so you really don't have to wait to find out what happens. This is not the case with my latest Dystopian obsession, The Scorch Trials. Cliff hangers abound and book three in the trilogy is a long way off!

What to say, this book was intense and wonderful. Book 2 was still good, and then comes book 3, and I was sadly so disappointed.

redhead: Yes, I'd also been hearing fantastic things about this book, which is why I decided to read it. And for the most part I pleased.

Jenny: That does make me feel better because the Mayor's motive in this book was just so weak that I was really disappointed. And I don't mind cliffhangers too much if the sequels are already in print.

JenStorySnoop: For me it was The Hunger Games that really turned me on to dystopian books. And it wasn't the cliff hanger that bothered me as the reasoning that is provided for why everyone was after Todd. It just didn't meet my expectations.

Blodeuedd: Oh no! Now I'm even more concerned about continuing on with the series if you were so disappointed by the last book. But then a lot of reader were unhappy with the last Hunger Games book, and I was pretty satisfied, so I guess I'll have to make my own judgments.

This is a series? Uggh, I skipped your spoilers because I really want to read it, but now I'm not so sure.

StephanieD: I think you would probably like this book. It's been very well received and I seem to be one of very few readers bothered by the ending.

Post a Comment

Thanks for leaving a comment!
I love hearing from you and I'll do my best to respond as soon as I can.


Book Reviews

Blog Archive

Blog Archive